After trying their "regular" Root Beer and their Natural Root Beer, I had high hopes for Boylan's Natural Cane Cola. Being under their "Natural" umbrella (as well as being slightly more expensive than their regular sodas) you'd expect high quality.
Well, that isn't the case here. This cola just has a not-so-nice mediciney taste to it once it hits your palate. I can taste the cinnamon (seems to be par for the course for any "natural" cola these days), but none of the bourbon vanilla. I'm guessing all the fruit oils they use are giving it the mediciney taste. Yeah, not that great. At the very least you don't get that nasty, generic cola aftertaste.
Sweetened With: "pure cane sugar"
Verdict: Worth trying at least once